Axel Tuanzebe’s Loan Signing Hints at Villa Player Departures

“I’m here to help us get promoted. The push for second place is more important than trying to make play-offs” – Axel Tuanzebe

Axel Tuanzebe Arrives

The arrival of 20-year-old Axel Tuanzebe from Manchester United is an intriguing loan signing, offering up more questions than the transfer actually provides answers.

Tuanzebe certainly talked a good game in his interviews when he was announced, repeating that his main aim was to help the team earn an automatic promotion spot.

Talk is cheap though when it comes to earning promotion, so how will his signing help Villa get back to the Premier League?


“The potential is there, you see it immediately,” said Jose Mourinho, of the United youngster, but future potential isn’t much currency to Villa. With it only being a loan for the rest of this season, Villa will need him to perform in the now.

The player surely would have only come to Villa if he and Mourinho had some reassurance from Steve Bruce, that he had the possibility of getting some decent game time.

Tuanzebe has only played five league games for United, so he is still raw at senior level. The loan from his and United’s point of view is to obviously address that.

Embed from Getty Images

Tuanzebe’s preferred roles are centre-back and defensive midfielder (he also made a start at right-back for the United first team), but you can’t see him being a starter in either position when he’s up against the former or present international players currently playing for Villa in those positions.

James Chester and John Terry as the centre-back partnership is set in stone. While Villa are spending a lot on wages on the three players – Mile Jedinak, Glenn Whelan and now Birkir Bjarnason – who cover the DM position.

One possibility for his loan could be a last attempt of Bruce to go with three at the back, adding Tuanzebe’s athletic and dynamic nature to help support Terry’s ageing limbs (think how Gareth Barry started out in a similar capacity for Villa).

This would also allow the Villa boss to play his favoured two up front.

But why make such changes now? When the players are finally getting to grips with each other as a team in the current system?

With his versatility and the fact he was United’s Reserve Player of the Year for 2017, certainly the United loanee would be useful cover for numerous permutations, especially, if Bruce is expecting some out-goings at the end of the transfer window.

Questions Raised

This brings us to the initial point of raising questions, is Tuanzebe arriving due to the fact that players will be departing in the final week?

Ritchie De Laet has gone, so that’s one player he can cover, but Villa already have options at right-back and overall they have depth in the squad.

Elphick’s Off?

Is the signing a clear indication that Tommy Elphick is actually heading out?

There’s already been rumours of Millwall and Leeds showing an interest in the centre-back. His recent improved showings for Villa and kudos from his Bournemouth days, would probably see Villa recoup an ok fee.

Jedinak’s Crock?

We haven’t really had a definitive status report on Jedinak’s injury status. One week, it’s he might need surgery, the next week, it’s he just needs to be rested.

The truth of the matter is Jedinak has been a bit-part player this season and his reliability is questionable.

Maybe signing Tuanzebe is an indication that the Aussie may have surgery, as he attempts to be 100% for the World Cup?

Birkir Bye?

Bjarnason has already done a U-turn this January transfer window. After being frozen out from the team, the Icelandic international was understandably looking for a move to Italy, but after recently breaking through into the first team he declared he wanted to stay.

Has there been a decent offer for him since? In the three or so days the Villa players were given off after the Barnsley game, Bjarnason headed off to spend time in Italy…

The plot thickens.

Onomah Return?

There’s been constant mutterings in the press of Josh Onomah potentially moving back to his parent club Spurs. He’s shown flashes of quality, but now faces tough competition to get back into the first team due to Jack Grealish’s emergence.

If he goes, then Tuanzebe is another midfield option to counter his absence.

Bottom Line

When you think about it, if Onomah returned to Spurs and Villa off-loaded either Elphick or Bjarnason, with De Laet already gone, a few holes in the squad would soon appear.

Factor in Jedinak’s dubious fitness at the moment, and Tuanzebe could be covering two to four players that have made minimal contributions this season, at a fraction of the cost.

His arrival does seem to point to the final days of the transfer window having some life left in them in terms of out-goings for Villa.

At the moment, it seems Axel Tuanzebe’s role is certainly at least that of a squad security blanket.


The best way to spend the weekend? Listen to the new MOMS podcast episode:


  1. I understand what everyone is saying but on a personal note I can’t believe that Bruce and the board are prepared to risk promotion at this stage of the season by not getting a striker in.

  2. I think there is a lot of sense in BBBs comments, I think the whole loan system needs to be reviewed, not just for the Villa, but in totality. We have players out on loan, and we are importing players on loan. The majority of incoming loanees are up and coming players from other teams. Why not try our own youngsters ?
    How can this foster a ongoing team spirit ? Perhaps I am too old school, but I would prefer to see a squad of committed Villa players getting to know each other and learning to play with each other on a regular basis. Oh for the days when you could win the league with 14 players …..

  3. Posted this elsewhere, but I’m extremely worried about the effect these loan signings are having on our squad. I recognise that we’re operating under financial fair play, and that these are talented young players we’re talking about, but if they’re routinely taking match day squad or even first team starting spots ahead of players we actually own, then we could have a problem.

    Take Johnstone first – a success story as far as loans go. We effectively wrote off another highly rated young goalkeeper in Gollini when Johnstone signed on loan a year ago. Although Johnstone has really impressed this season, he currently remains a Manchester United player and other teams will have noted his fine form. If we can’t secure a permanent deal for him (not a certainity even if we achieve promotion) we could find ourselves two goalkeepers down in summer and back to square one.

    Then there’s Onomah and Snodgrass. Their presence helped push Bjarnason out of the pecking order earlier this season and forced him into the utility role. Now, while Snodgrass has really done well, Onomah has looked less impressive especially as of late. Meanwhile, we risk losing Bjarnason who’s done really well in the last few games, and again, there’s no guarantee that we’ll keep Snodgrass next season, and Onomoah will most likely return the Spurs regardless. With Jedinak not getting any oyunger and seemingly incapable of putting together a string of games for the claret and blue, do we really want to lose a talented international with Champion’s League experience as well?

    Then there’s our defence. Chester and Terry are the preferred central partnership, no doubt. This is hard on Elphick, who despite being third or fourth pick for the position (just like Bjarnason) performed really well over Chrismas and New Year before Terry made his return and walked back into the team. Now he’ got Tuanzebe pushing him further down the pecking order. It’s doubtul we’ll retain Terry for another season. It’s doubtful we’ll retain Samba for another season. Emergency centre half Jedinak is unreliable – see above. And – just like Onomah – Tuanzebe is much more likely to return to Manchester United than sign a permanent contract with us, whether we achieve promotion this year or not. So let me get this straight, we’re ready and willing to push Elphick out of the squad and probably out the door, when we’re likely to lose up to FOUR first team players in his position in summer?

    The results at the moment speak for themselves, but I’m struggling to see the sense in this strategy long term.

Comments are closed.