Aston Villa Horror Show Performance Raises Big Concerns

Aston Villa Need to Address Growing Pains

At the Emirates, Aston Villa served up one of their worst performances under Dean Smith in their 3-1 defeat to Arsenal.

It was if the game carried on directly from the disastrous last 10 minutes against Wolves at Villa Park, the week before.

The answers to whether the 3-5-2 formation was designed to be the way forward for this season will no doubt be answered in the next few weeks. It’s understandable that it’s been reverted to considering Villa have had away trips to Chelsea, Manchester United, Spurs and Arsenal in the first nine games. There’s also injuries to key wide players (Leon Bailey, Bertrand Traore and Trezeguet all haven’t started this season), which the formation helps compensate for.

But were Danny Ings and Axel Tuanzebe acquired to purposely play it? Was it an intended formation despite Villa’s injury issues?

There’s no doubt that the wing-backs have struggled with the defensive requirements of the formation, with club’s already working it out. The centre-backs too have struggled, with Konsa and Mings having to come wide to the full back position to cover their wayward wing-backs.

While largely astute in their positioning in a centre-back pairing, Konsa and Mings have been all at sea at times in their positioning within a back three, while Tuanzebe has been far from assured.

With players returning back to the fold for the winter months, supporters will soon get insight into how Smith really wants to set up.

At this point in time, reverting back to a back four should cue the fundamental problems, while we see what works best up top.

In the latest My Old Man Said podcast episode, the MOMS team looks at the situation rationally and explains while the performance at the Emirates is far from acceptable, it’s not actually time for panic stations just yet.

Also, there’s triple Media Muppet activity, a ‘Three Points’ section that includes a 40-0 win and much, much, much more.


Listen Below

My Old Man Said on Apple Podcasts iTunes

Listener Offer

Penfold Bonus Code

This episode of the My Old Man Said podcast is brought to you by Penfold, pension experts for the self-employed and pensionless. Sign-up to get yourself a flexible and easy-to-set up pension and take advantage of the 25% Government tax bonus and compound interest from an expertly managed fund to build your long-term future. 

Get yourself a bonus ¬£50 on MOMS in your pension fund, by signing up here – getpenfold/moms and using the code MOMS

With pensions, as with all investments your capital is at risk. The value of what you put in may go up as well as down.



  1. Surely that was was a 2-3-5 formation with `2 CB’s & 3 half backs in front of them ? But with modern tactics like the Gooners it in all probability would not work . With 3 at back we really need to have a strong Center bak who can cover the goal with 2 wide players & we don’t seem to have a player strong enough to play the lone CB

  2. Why not go with something completely different, for e.g. GK, LB, CH, RB, LH, RH, OL, IL, CF, IR, OR. It used to work alright for us, probably called 3-2-5 nowadays. C’mon Dean get it sorted before it costs you your job. UTV

  3. A back 3 does not work against a team of cheats such as the Gooners who attack & defend enmasse ! And I say that as their penalty before half time should not have happened as the whistle should already have gone for a foul on a Villa player in the box had happened just before the penalty incident ! Also too many Villa players were ending up on deck after being pulled backwards when off the Ball

Comments are closed.