What We Learned As Villa Fans From The Start of The Season

Before a ball was kicked, Villa were favourites to win the league and even without their top scorer the marquee signing of John Terry, who had looked the part throughout pre-season, it was encouraging enough for fans to have a little flutter.

With Bruce’s old team Hull to start proceedings the scene was set for a flying start in front of the home fans and some overdue restored belief that Villa were on the up.

And then after 45 minutes or so, it went downhill faster than a Chelsea forward in the penalty area.


Villa really took it to Hull in the first half, and would have been disappointed to only be up by a single goal. Of course, it had to be beleaguered striker Gabby Agbonlahor to net the first goal of the season – a player Bruce still stakes his reputation on especially with Kodjia out with his long-term injury.

And then in the second half, Villa looked as flat as they looked at their dullest last season.

When Hull made it 1-1 it wasn’t much of a surprise as Villa had offered nothing – all too familiar after going up a goal last season. And by the final whistle, a point was a fair result – sadly. If the intensity of the first half had been kept up, Villa would have strolled it.

It looked like the same old Villa of last season – no plan B (except for the dying minutes when Samba was thrown on as an emergency target man) and a lack of creativity and self-belief given that their newly-relegated opponents had gotten used to losing and were there for the taking.

So fans learned that the summer didn’t seem to have made much difference to the product on the field. More of the same we had endured since Bruce took over.


The Haribo (whatever) Cup game a few days later was nearly called off. The torrential rain in Colchester put the match in real doubt, but it went ahead and had some entertaining and enlightening moments for fans.

With young players like Callum O’Hare making a rare appearance – and putting in a good shift – Colchester United were surely a walkover but while the conditions played their part, United had a plan and it was working for them.

The narrow (score wise) win didn’t tell the full story. And the real encouraging part wasn’t that Villa would be in the next round but that the young players waiting for their chance had looked good.

Embed from Getty Images

Was there a chance we would see some of them keeping out the familiar cloggers that had looked so anonymous against Hull when Villa travelled to Cardiff for the next game?


Of course not. Gabby and the old guard were back for the trip to Cardiff and let the club down badly.

The 0-3 defeat and one shot on target was a Paul Lambert stat line.

Among the most disappointing players were Chester, Terry and Whelan – the nuts and bolts of the machine, who in theory, can let the more offensive players do their thing.

It was poor all over. Onomah’s viral video run at the City defence was probably the highlight of the afternoon. And while he was visibly upset and ponderous at where it had all gone wrong, the knives were out and being sharpened and aimed at Steve Bruce by many angry fans.

McLeish might not have stood a chance from some fans given his previous employers, but Bruce would without a doubt been forgiven and cheered if he could have got Villa back up last season – or at least playing some sharp football – regardless of playing for Manchester United AND Birmingham City.

Perhaps the hole he found the team in was too deep, but he had his transfer window, the deadwood that wanted out or that he didn’t fancy were being chipped away… yet the fresh start to the season had already been soured after just two league games.

This wasn’t just about the results. This was about poor performance, mismanagement of player positions, and a belief in his strongest XI that haven’t put in a dominant 90 minutes since he took the job.

Would he be given much longer to turn things around? Some fans are calling for his head already. Others on social media were suggesting 10 games was fair.


Oh, and Leandro Bacuna – a player who has a suspect temperament, lacks ability and doesn’t have much of a footballing brain – was sold reportedly for almost four times what we paid for him. So at least there’s that.

Embed from Getty Images


The game against Reading – who are a good side in this division – was a new low point.

In the first half, Villa were nothing short of awful. A new formation and new line-up spoke to some fans concerns but two right-backs on the bench created new ones.

Bruce is certainly under pressure, and with too many more first halves like that he will be off the bench and into a TV pundit’s seat. Villa

Villa were miserable. Couldn’t connect two passes, struggled to find a shot, and Reading made it look like they were toying with them.

Once Gabby chested the ball down to Hourihane to make it 2-1, an extremely unlikely equaliser was on the cards… for about three minutes.

It was a bad, bad day at the office. And a sign, as we saw under Lambert repeatedly, that there is no plan B that makes changes to the on-field performances for the better.


Follow Adam on Twitter at @keebo00


Subscribe for free to be prepared for more good stuff – Acast / iTunes / Tunein / Stitcher / PlayerFM 


    • Cheers for the heads up. Something weird was happening with an external spell/grammar check plug-in I was trying. When you pressed return to move a paragraph, it seemed to leave a copy of the paragraph in the original location. Looks like it has a compatibility problem. Thanks again.

  1. Two schools of thought – too early to judge after three games, or the record not good enough over ten months. He’s had thirty-eight games. W15, D8, L15. So 53 points from 114. Over a forty-six game season, that ratio gets you 64 points, which Brentford had last season, finishing tenth. The flaw in those stats of course is that they are heavily weighted to his record last season. But he’s had his close season, and two transfer windows, so are we making progress? No sign of it yet, in fact it feels like the opposite. Norwich on Saturday, then Wigan in the cup (who spotted the potential of Portsmouth’s League Two winning manager and signed him up, so maybe Plan C should be to ignore the usual suspects and look for an up and coming manager with new ideas) then Bristol City away. A good seven days for Bruce may ease the pressure. But a bad seven days and we will need to act sooner rather than later.

  2. I was watching one of the friendlys and thought we have a real talent in one of the younger players it was jake hayes, in his 20min spell he did what the rest of the midfield had not done all game, forced errors from the other side, he was winning balls, and forcing our players forward, just what we need. never heard of him after that

  3. And all Bruce can offer is that Newcastle lost their first 2 games last season and still won the league !. I commented in an earlier column about our shots on target ratio compared to other teams. We have had 4 in the last 180 minutes. Will somebody tell Bruce that to win football matches we need to score goals, and to do that we need to shoot ? I can’t believe that the previously good 2nd level players we signed – Hogan, Lansbury, etc have become poor players overnight. There is clearly something wrong with tactics in that we are far too negative and are stifling the skills and strengths of such players. I saw another stat about Villa’s record since the turn of 2017 – a month after Calderwood joined as Bruce’s assistant. What a dynamic duo they have turned out to be.
    We could be bottom of the Championship by Saturday morning; Unthinkable

  4. AV will bot be Top 6 or anywhere close. Championship needs pace and power and some craft with goals. We don’t have any of this in the players on show. We will struggle, change manager, get worse and management will do what they do best, tweet.

  5. WHERE IS THE PASSION THEY PLAY FOR ASTON VILLA FOR GODS SAKE.,……………… Gabby got to go. He just not got it… good servant for the club but probably been here for. 5 years to long. Lansbury looks dreadful. Hutton needs to go. Hogan so injury prone and not a £1 million pound player let alone what we paid for him.
    I’m still undecided on Bruce, bring in director of football such as big Sam. So they can sit down and sort this shambles out. We are a big club everybody keeps saying this but the moment we look like team (I use the word loosely) that could be at the end of the season in a dog fight.
    If I’m at work and don’t perform they stop your wages or loose ya job. Try docking every player 50 percent of there wages until they can prove themselves worthy of full payment LETS SEE WHAT HAPPENS THEN

  6. Let’s be honest it is schocking and totaly unacceptable and to suggest giving Bruce 10 games is a joke, after that many games the points situation could well be too far gone to retrieve, what people don’t seem to realise is if we don’t achieve promotion this season we will certainly loose Kodjia and one or two more and then it really will be curtains for years.
    My opinion Bruce needs to go now, we need to get a new striker in straight away stop playing Green he’s clearly not up to it no way we can miss the clear cut chances that he misses just costing us results, get shot of Gabby ASAP. get our youngsters out of the under 23s and play them in the first team then and only then we might see a bit of an improvement, but I say again not with clueless Bruce in charge.

Comments are closed.