Aston Villa Boss Dean Smith Reaction – Beyond the One of Our Own Hype


The announcement of Aston Villa’s new boss Dean Smith, threw up several what-ifs. Would Theirry Henry have taken the job, if the AS Monaco opportunity hadn’t materialised? Would Jose Mourinho’s long-term assistant, Rui Faria, had done any better as a number one than Carlos Ancelotti’s right-hand man, Paul Clement? Would John Terry have had a chance at being Villa’s number one, if he had completed his coaching badges in time?

The thinking that Smith had been third or even fourth choice to be the new Aston Villa boss is largely immaterial now, and the way it has eventually panned out, he could potentially end up being the best option for Villa.

Looking beyond the ‘One of Our Own’ hype (he’s a Villa supporter, like you and I), Smith has a real chance to help revolutionise the club on the footballing side and create his career legacy.

To the marquee name ala Henry, the Villa job would have carried the big risk of devaluing their stock in the game, like many recent Villa managers before them. There was little infrastructure on the footballing side present at Villa and the whiff of FFP issues is still very much in the air.

It’s a job not for the faint of heart.

Villa Surgery

Villa needed a man committed to the cause, who could help perform footballing surgery for the best of the club, as opposed to using it as a stepping stone for himself.

Smith already had insight to the club as a life-long fan, but more importantly, he’s faced Villa five times in recent Championship seasons and never lost. He fully knows Villa’s weaknesses from first hand experience and analysis.

Exposing them is one thing, fixing them is an entirely different matter though.

We will discuss the ins and outs of what Dean Smith can bring to Villa, based on his career so far, in another longer article, but in terms of first impressions, as we discussed in the latest MOMS podcast episode, as well as Smith bringing more attacking and progressive football to Villa, he has to make it winning football too.

Press Play to Listen

Winning Football?

As we point out on the podcast, while opportunity has very much knocked for Smith, he got the job more on his coaching prowess and potential, rather than tangible achievements as a manager in terms of results.

His highest finish in any league across eight seasons, whether with Walsall or Brentford, has been 9th.

Oddly, this season at Brentford, after a start full of optimism this season, Smith’s last five games were winless and his Brentford team still hadn’t won away this season. Some Bees fans were even questioning whether he could take them to the next level.

Now that is Villa’s concern. Can Smith take the club to the next level of the Premier League?

Villa have been sensible with the length of his contract at two-and-a-half years, which will no doubt be swiftly extended, if the next year or so proves to be successful.

Smith is believed to have tripled his £300k-a-year Brentford salary, but you have to say that he may have increased his chances of promotion three-fold when you consider his newly acquired resources.

It’s a massive shame that Smith doesn’t get a summer preseason to begin the transition of the footballing style and ethos of the team. Still, the Championship has offered up few outstanding teams so far this season, so Villa are still in touch of at least the play-offs, despite the woeful start that saw Bruce lose his job.

Hopefully, simply by bringing some clarity to the way they will play and unshackling several of the players, Smith should make progress straight away.

It will not be hard to improve on the recent footballing approach of the club.


As mentioned before we’ll discuss all the facets that Smith brings to the job in a longer form piece and also a more considered podcast episode. 

New on Spotify

Other news regarding the My Old Man Said podcast is that it’s now available on the world’s biggest music streaming platform Spotify. If you already use Spotify, just search My Old Man Said and ‘follow’ to get instant updates when new shows drop.

MOMS #53.5: Dean Smith Reaction – Beyond #OneOfOurOwn Hype

A bonus two-part episode first of all reacts to Aston VIlla’s appointment of Dean Smith as Head Coach. David Michael and Chris Budd give their first impressions and play the devil advocate at times to make sure it’s not just a hype job.

Brentford fans, as well as being happy with Smith’s style of play, have often raised concerns about their gaffer not being able to kill teams off, so can he add a more ruthless mentality to his make-up at Villa? As he’ll need to beat his career best 9th place finish! Also, what’s John Terry’s role in the new look Villa coaching staff?

In the second part of the show, Dan Rodgers joins the duo to answer listener questions – from JT, Villa’s lack of continuity from academy to first team, Villa’s best back four. Memories of Cahill, Ridgewell, Baker,Clarke, Graham Turner and pyjama bottoms are all visited.

Also, the show features some Villa-isms from Dean Smith himself.

The show is also now available on Spotify.

Enjoy & UTV



If you want the show to continue and be more frequent, please do support the show by either a one-off tip here (no matter how small) or better still, by becoming a MOMS Patron. You will get bonus patron-only episodes, advanced sneaks and also get entered into regular reward draws. More details and to become a Patron, click here: Join MOMS Patrons


David Michael – @oldmansaid 

Dan Rodgers – @avfc_vilr

Chris Budd – @BUDD_music

Producer/Editor – David Michael

Voices – Dan Rodgers

My Old Man Said –

Villa Underground –


  1. About the whole Smith being 3rd or 4th choice. The only thing i would point out is 3 days before Bruce was sacked, the new owners put in a further 2.7million of new shares into the club.

    Once Bruce was sacked, the Bham Mail reported that the departed quartet received 2.3million between them.

    It has since then been reported that we paid 0.3 for Smith, with abit of rounding, and lawyers fees would equate to the 2.7 the owners knew we needed to replace the manager, that seems to fit all too nicely for my liking.

    I would argue he was first choice, and the owners knew thats who we should get, however they did their due dilligence and interviewed others as well, as well you have to these days, and the american would be used to the rooney rule, which is why i assume Henry probably got an interview aswell.

    Ofcourse i might be wrong, maybe he was 4th choice, but this story only seems to come out about because the news outlets (who have no access to any sources at villa i might add) made him 1st choice and made others first choice, i saw the “breaking news from Sky Sports” twice that they “understand” henry with terry as his Nr 1, and faria were both set to agree to become the manager, yet then out of the blue, it was announced that it was Smith, with no warning from any sources.

    Funny how Sky also own a betting service….

  2. I’m wishing Dean Smith all the best of luck but why we read that his first two signings should be a winger and a midfielder is anyone’s guess we already have ElGhazi and Bolasie and we haven’t been playing them, maybe I have missed something but I was under the impression that we need defenders and if possible a decent goal keeper.
    I really hope this doesn’t turn out to be same old same old, but I say again I’m pleased that Dean Smith is here and I wish him luck.

Comments are closed.