Ultimate Villa Player Ratings for Craven Cottage Cop Out

By Jonathan Parkin

We are constantly being told about the ‘Magic of the FA Cup’ (I think the BBC have applied to ™ it), there’s no such thing, unless you’re a lower league team with an improved chance of going on longer cup runs due to understrength teams. Aston Villa’s tie away against Fulham certainly won’t be one that’s replayed in years to come. Other than two screamers from Fulham’s Anthony Knockaert and Harry Arter, the quality on show was woeful.

It’s never nice to see the Villa lose a game, but at least some consolation can come from a weekend off in late January. It was a game that neither team really wanted to win, but the Villans wanted it less. The second-string line-up did little to inspire, and it’s hard to see many of them pushing for a place in the starting XI when the Carabao cup Semi-Final rolls around.

Use code MOMS10 for an extra 10% off below

Player ratings

Orjan Nyland – 7

The big Norwegian Orjan Nyland kept Villa in the game a number of times with some good saves. His claiming of crosses was decent; however, his distribution is shaky at best.

Ahmed Elmohamady – 4

Ahmed Elmohamady did nothing to inspire confidence at right-back. He put in a few passable balls, but his defensive work was poor.

Bjorn Engels – 5

Bjorn Engels looked a step off the pace all game, and he looked anything but sturdy in defence all game. He did little to close the Fulham attackers when they ran at the backline, and so Fulham had plenty of chances.

James Chester – 6

James Chester didn’t show any reasons as to why he should be considered over Konsa, Mings or Hause for selection. He still easing his way back after a long lay-off, but the reality is his Premier League days maybe over.

Neil Taylor – 4

There was nothing new from Neil Taylor. Knockaert ran him ragged all game, and scored because the Welshman allowed him breeze past him to cut inside and take a shot.

Marvellous Nakamba – 4

Marvellous Nakamba tried relatively hard, but was all over the place. He gave the ball away sloppily on a number of occasions and didn’t help his cause when he got himself booked lunging in early on. He doesn’t completely fill you with much confidence when he picks up the ball in front of the centre-halves.

Conor Hourihane – 6

Conor Hourihane’s passing was relatively tidy as ever, but he lacked real energy to influence the game He played in some menacing balls from out wide and set-pieces, but didn’t do much else.

Henri Lansbury – 5

Once again Henri Lansbury ran about a bit. It seems to be all he can do, he offered very little to the Villa midfield throughout. Fulham were able to play through the midfield with ease at times, and Lansbury’s presence or lack there-of didn’t help things.

Jota – 5

Jota played one nice ball to Kodjia for the Villa goal. One good ball does not make a good performance. The Spaniard really hasn’t shown much to get Villa fans excited so far.

Anwar El Ghazi – 5

El Ghazi should’ve scored at the end of the first half, and if that had gone in who knows what could’ve happened. The winger was caught running with his head down time after time yet again, and his tracking back was pretty non-existent once more.

Jonathan Kodjia – 6

Jonathan Kodjia provided most of the threat for the boys in claret and blue throughout the 90 minutes, the problem was he was offside and gave the ball away far too many times. Though he was the most threatening of the team, it wasn’t a display that’ll have many fans jumping for joy about the prospect of him starting next time out.

Off the Bench

Trezeguet (75) – 4

After he came off the bench it’s hard to remember if Trezeguet actually impacted the game in the slightest. There wasn’t even his trademark energy down the flank.

Indiana Vassilev (79) – N/A

It was good to see Indiana Vassilev get on the pitch for his debut, but the game really passed the 18-year-old by.

Jacob Ramsey (85) – N/A

Again, it was good to see youngster Ramsey get on the pitch, however the rest of the team had seemingly given up by the time he entered the fray.

Manager Rating

Dean Smith- 5

It can easily be seen that Dean Smith hardly had the lads fired up for the cup. However, with two League Cup semi-finals and relegation battles around the corner, another cup run is hardly the priority.

Still, there was enough on the pitch to win the game and it would have been good to see at least a bit more fight from the players though. It certainly doesn’t inspire any confidence in the back-up players in the squad. They had a great chance to make an impression, but yet again, let themselves down. Why aren’t these players motivated?


Follow Jonathan on Twitter here – @JonParkinSports

The MOMS Podcast returns this week…


  1. I thought Jota showed touches of class. Set up the goal with his pass to Kodjia. Took a ball down on his chest and got off a good shot. His performance isn’t as good as El Gazi, but better than Trez. Other than that and Kodjia looking lively, we simply didn’t have enough spark. Defense, very poor, almost amateurish at times. Fulham deserved to win.

  2. When you consider the youngsters that Liverpool put out against Everton you realise very quickly that each and everyone of them played the Liverpool way – coaching without doubt. What is going on at Villa with our youngsters. To add to this it has struck me how long it takes to return a player after injury compared with other clubs. What is wrong with the backroom staff? Change is needed without delay.
    As for the first team well, at least 4 or 5 QUALITY players required NOW.. Deans ideas for tactics are questionable, adventurist yes, but so easily countered by a half decent team.

  3. Agree w/ Colin, time for Villa and Purslow to open the bank and bring in 3 or 4 quality premier league players. Maybe go for some expensive loans just to get us to safety. I play keeper in a pub team and always play better with a run in the team and the same defenders in front of me. Just tell Nyland now (as Norway’s #1) he is our starting keeper and we are sticking with him. Spend the money on the areas we badly need to improve; Left back/ Center midfield/ 2 strikers. We’ve a pool of talent at center-back (that’s why DS is gonna stick with 3 of them each game) so if we improve in other areas and keep Captain Jack in a free role (5-3-1-1) we can get the 6 or 7 wins we need! UTV

  4. Nyland was ok apart from the goals which we set up for them, what was Makamba doing for the first, showing his man inside instead of pushing him wide, do they not discuss these situations in training, “he has a great left foot lets let him come inside and then lay off and let him have a shot”, i think it was obvious if anyone was going to score it would be him, he bossed the game. Chester showed his class, would also be better in a better team, put him back in with Mings. as for the rest,”PATHETIC”.the ratings are too generous.

  5. Same old same old no fire power, Kodja looked better than Wesley so needs to start if we don’t sign a quality striker before our next game. And as for being linked with Hart What are the club thinking about, do me a favour he’s been garbage for years, we have to do better a quality replacement is urgently needed I mean quality not Hart and a quality striker, come on Villa this is about staying up not being relegated, we need to get players in now not at the end of the window.

Comments are closed.