Ultimate Aston Villa Player Ratings For the Forest Home Game

After drawing three of their first four home games, a win against Nottingham Forest was always going to be a statement of intent for the rest of the season.

The feeling at full-time though was one more of relief than the half-time expectation of a potentially comfortable win.

Forest will ultimately count themselves unlucky, after Villa lost all authority on the second-half, until a Hourihane freekick set them up for the win and Johnstone got them over the line.

There was something of a lack of cohesion in Villa’s play, but Villa’s team is packed with enough quality at this level to win games on indifferent days.

Grinding out results is a good asset, but Villa will have to learn how to turn on the style too, if they want to convince fans of their promotion ambitions.

Embed from Getty Images

Aston Villa Player Ratings vs Barnsley

Sam Johnstone – 7 

Steady and composed once again and his save from the free kick save his key contribution.

Ahmed Elmohamady – 6

Another spirited performance that currently keeps him in the team above three out-and-out right-backs. A little restricted going forward, but dogged in defence.

John Terry – 7

He let a man almost as old as him ghost through to score Forest’s equaliser, but that was one blip on a performance where he largely marshalled the defence well, especially later on in the game, although he wasn’t helped by his midfield at times.

James Chester – 6

He also contributed to Forest’s equaliser and got caught out a couple of times, but luck was on his side. He’s had better games, but did enough to get Villa over the line.

Neil Taylor – 7

Another no thrills spirited performance with the odd crucial intervention from the Welsh battler. He’s certainly defensively sound when it comes to his defensive duties, something that has been a rare quality amongst Villa full-backs in recent seasons.

Glen Whelan – 5  (If he was a Forest player – 7)

Seemed to be a fading force in the middle of the park. His main remit seems to be to break up play, but it had been hoped he would help Villa keep possession and help things tick over in the middle of the park. In that respect, he was disappointing. Also, not convincing as a ‘midfield enforcer’.

Robert Snodgrass – 5

Overall a disappointing outing for Snodgrass. A wasteful freekick (although it ultimately contributed to the winner, with Hourihane taking over duties later) and the fact he seemed a little off the pace, were the underlining points of his performance.

Hopefully his sharpness will return this coming week against Burton and Bolton.

Conor Hourihane – 7

Showed good effort, although did a lot of chasing due to Forest’s possession. His freekick winner was one of the reasons he was brought to the club and with it being his fifth goal already this season, he hasn’t disappointed when it comes to the big stats.

Keinan Davis – 7

Once again good vision and feet created chances for others, although he only had one shot of note himself. There’s a positive trend already appearing from Davis’ performances, he’s at least a solid 7/10 man every game.

The more Villa get him into the game, the better off they’ll be.

Jonathan Kodjia – 6.5

While he’s not exactly firing on all cylinders at the moment, he’s starting to make things happen. He won the freekick and also assisted in Adomah’s opener.

Expect his first goal of the season this coming week!

Albert Adomah – 8 (MOTM)

It’s fair to say Adomah is producing his best form in a Villa shirt in the past few weeks. At the start of the season his role at Villa was uncertain with the influx of new signings, but now he’s one of the first names on the team sheet.

A genuine threat going forward with his alertness and forward intent leading to his recent goal haul. He was perhaps unlucky not to score another brace, after a neat opener.

His increased work rate has also been a revelation.

Off the Bench…

Hogan (79) – 5

The usual Hogan scenario. Lots of running, nothing to hang onto though

Onomah (72) – 5

Didn’t settle into the game and for once, made little impression.

Hutton (88) – N/A

He’s still alive. That’s about all that can be said from his sub appearance in the final minutes. He came on to help preserve the lead and we won.


Plenty of Villa fun and frolics in the latest podcast show episode


  1. Can’t expect to stomp over all other teams. A win will do. Problems in quality will be addressed if we win promotion, or we’ll come straight back down.

  2. But if Forest had won the toss and chamged it around wouldn’t Villa have kicked off …? Interesting

    • Yep. Forest definitely kicked off at the start of the first half, and we kicked off the second. So we must have chosen ends. Unless the standard of refereeing in this league is worse than I thought

  3. Missed the two previous home games before yesterday (out of the country). So, question – Forest kicked off, so we must have won the toss, so we must have chosen to kick toward the Holte in the first half. Was this a one off?

      • Forest kicked off. Promise. Watch the highlights if you still can. Said to the guy next to me, how come Forest are kicking off, but we are kicking toward the Holte? Law 8. The team that wins the toss chooses ends, the other team kicks off. Then just to make sure I wasnt imagining things, checked at start of second half. We kicked off the second half

  4. Forest unlucky ? Yes they were unlucky to end match with all 11 players still on the pitch another ref might havehad them finishing with 8
    As for Terry allowing their goal, after the goal scorer scythed , or should that be bulldozed through our defence trying to see how many of our players would be penalised for trying to stop him . Think Terry & the team were exercising extreme restraint as both he & Davis were both involved in fistycuffs that could have ended in brawls

Comments are closed.