Five Reasons to be Cheerful: Kamara Returns and more
After a flurry of incomings and outgoings, the transfer merry-go-round has slowed at Villa Park, with a couple more departures seemingly needed before the summer reshuffle can continue. Pre-season has gathered pace, players are steadily returning from injury and World Cup duty, and attention is beginning to turn towards the UEFA Super Cup showdown with Paris Saint-Germain.
Madjo Magic
One of the week’s most encouraging developments was the confirmation that Brian Madjo will be part of the first-team squad this season. With Ollie Watkins still enjoying an extended break following the World Cup and Tammy Abraham working his way back from shoulder surgery, the teenager has been handed valuable minutes throughout pre-season.
Rather than merely making up the numbers, Madjo has looked remarkably comfortable at senior level. His physicality, movement, and composure in front of goal all belie his age, suggesting Villa may have another exciting talent emerging from within.
Expectations should remain realistic. He doesn’t need to become Villa’s next breakout star overnight. But if he can chip in with a handful of meaningful contributions while continuing his development, supporters may begin to experience the same growing excitement they felt during Jhon Durán’s emergence. Definitely one to watch.
Good Nacho
Alejandro Garnacho’s first outing in Bangkok left plenty of room for improvement. Whether it was a lack of confidence, match sharpness, or simply unfamiliarity with Unai Emery’s demands, the Argentine looked hesitant throughout. His decision-making in possession was often rushed, he drifted out of the game for long periods without the ball, and, perhaps most surprisingly, seemed reluctant to attack his full-back when isolated out wide.
It certainly wasn’t the statement debut many had hoped for, but neither should it define expectations. Garnacho is arriving at a club with a clearly structured tactical system, having endured a difficult final year elsewhere. Restoring confidence and reshaping his game was never going to happen in 45 minutes of pre-season football.
After delivering silverware back to Villa Park, Emery has more than earned the club’s trust in the transfer market. His enthusiasm when Garnacho arrived at Bodymoor Heath suggested this is a player he genuinely believes he can develop. Given Emery’s track record of improving young talent, supporters have every reason to reserve judgement.
It’s also easy to forget that Garnacho is only marginally older than Morgan Rogers was when he arrived at Villa. The ability has never been in doubt; the challenge has always been applying it consistently. If anyone has earned the right to unlock that potential, it’s Emery.
Perhaps the most reassuring aspect of the deal is its structure. Thanks in no small part to UEFA’s continued scrutiny of Villa’s finances (and Chelsea’s), the move is not an unconditional £40 million gamble. Garnacho will only become a permanent Villa player if specific conditions are met and, more importantly, if he convinces Emery that he is worth the investment.
If anyone doubts Emery’s willingness to walk away from a loan signing who fails to reach the required standard, they need only look back at Harvey Elliott’s short-lived spell last season. Reputation alone won’t earn Garnacho a permanent move. His performances will.
Kamara Chameleon
Boubacar Kamara’s return to Bangkok was one of the most welcome sights of pre-season, particularly after Amadou Onana’s long-term injury. Kamara remains the heartbeat of Emery’s midfield, and with João Gomes now arriving, there will potentially be a new dynamic to Villa’s midfield. The duo have yet to play alongside each other in pre-season, so it’ll be interesting to see if Emery starts the pair this week against Bayern Munich.
Kamara’s goal on his return served as a timely reminder that Kamara could potentially play further forward in Villa’s midfield, with Gomes playing as the deeper of the two. Another midfield addition to cover Onana would be useful, as it would allow Villa to manage Kamara’s minutes more effectively this season. No more early-round domestic cup games for him.
Last chance to get a sponsor-free shirt
Jamaican Me Crazy
Leon Bailey’s Villa career appears to be drawing to a close and, while his departure may not generate the headlines of some other exits, it could prove one of the most significant.
A transfer fee combined with the removal of his sizeable wages would give Villa valuable flexibility to strengthen elsewhere, particularly in the right-forward position that has remained an unresolved issue for some time.
Bailey’s spell in claret and blue has ultimately been undermined by injuries and inconsistency, but it shouldn’t be forgotten that his outstanding 2023/24 campaign played a huge role in securing Champions League football for the first time in the Premier League era.
Sometimes a move simply arrives at the right time for everyone involved. The player needs to reignite his career, Villa need financial room to get in a decent right-hand side attacking threat, and it would represent sensible business all round.
Listen to the latest My Old Man Said podcast
Sound of Silence
In an era where every social media account claims to have exclusive transfer information every 20 minutes, Villa’s approach this summer has been refreshingly understated.
The arrivals of João Gomes and Johan Manzambi emerged with relatively little warning, suggesting Roberto Olabe and the recruitment team are operating with impressive professionalism behind the scenes.
Supporters naturally crave transfer news, but there is something reassuring about a club that conducts its business quietly rather than negotiating through anonymous accounts on X. The less the internet knows about Villa’s next move, the better.
After all, silence can be golden, while social media noise like that surrounding Emi Martinez is just irritating.
UTV
Follow Armen on Twitter/X here – @VillanArmen
Get MOMS in your inbox every Friday, free. Sharp, funny, informative Villa writing for supporters who can spot the clickbait from the back of the Holte. No spam. Join the astonvilla.wtf newsletter →
Follow MOMS on Twitter/X & Facebook & Threads & Bluesky
Listen to the Podcast on Apple and Spotify