Aston Villa Squad Assessment – Who’s Underrated or Overrated

Aston Villa Squad Assessment – Who’s Underrated or Overrated

When you consider the players who played the most minutes for Aston Villa during the 2022/23 season and formed the foundation of the team’s successful journey into Europe, Ezri Konsa and Tyrone Mings emerge as the top two. This fact speaks volumes about the club’s progression, as even these two dependable players now face competition for their positions. Not only is Diego Carlos back in shape and eager to make his mark, but there’s also a newcomer in town, none other than Pau Torres, who previously played as a center-back under Unai Emery at Villarreal. With over £60m worth of center-back talent nipping at their heels, Konsa and Mings are facing serious challenges.

Under Emery, Villa supporters saw a dramatic uplift in the performance levels by several key players such as the two aforementioned centre-backs, John McGinn, Douglas Luiz and Ollie Watkins. You get the feeling though, they’ll have to go up yet another level and stay consistent to remain prime movers in the Spaniards plans.

Underrated or Overrated?

With that in mind and with the transfer window in full swing, now is a good time to look at the current Aston Villa squad under Unai Emery and access them on the My Old Man Said podcast. For a bit of extra fun, we’ve done it in our tried and tested format of ‘underrated or overrated’. It’s not quite as binary as ‘good or bad’, or ‘positive or negative’.

Some players you’ll be able to second guess, but what about the likes of Leon Bailey and Emi Buendia? We go through everyone who played minutes for Villa last season, from the 10 minute man Morgan Sanson to Ezri Konsa, who featured in every Premier League game.

The show is in two parts, or if you’re a My Old Man Said member, you can access it in an ad-free full-length complete version.



Listen to the show below or on any good podcast app.

Huge VPN Savings and Bonus Gift

NordVPN Offer

This episode of the My Old Man Said podcast is sponsored by NordVPN, which was named as one of TIME’s 2022 Best Inventions (Apps and Software section). As well as protecting your privacy and online data, NordVPN allows you the opportunity to save you money by purchasing subscriptions(and flights) from other countries at a cheaper price. Plus, of course, it will help you watch Sporting Events/TV Shows/Films which aren’t available in your region by switching your virtual location to a country which is screening it.

With the MOMS deal on NordVPN, you can get the Fastest VPN in the world for the price of a coffee a month, while being able to try it risk-free with a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Get your MOMS EXCLUSIVE NordVPN deal here ➼ 


If you want ad-free advance versions of the shows and extra exclusive shows during the month and to join My Old Man Said’s 24/7 Villa community, Match Club, please do support the show by becoming a MOMS Member.

For more details and to become a member, click here: Become a MOMS Member

Follow the show on Twitter at @myoldmansaid and join the show’s listener facebook group The Mad Few.

T-Shirt, Mugs & Merch Listeners can now buy a MOMS Podcast T-shirt or mug to show their support of the show and look cool, check out the MOMS SHOP to buy.


David Michael – @myoldmansaid 

Chris Budd – @BUDD_music

Phillip Shaw – @prsgame

This Podcast has been created and uploaded by My Old Man Said. The views in this Podcast are not necessarily the views of talkSPORT


  1. Great chat for one and all (in part one) and well said on the players mentioned regarding overated or underated? I have agreed on all fronts with what was said too, so looking forward to part two guys, keep up the good work…Brilliant ! UTV.

Comments are closed.