Will Looking Back With Anger at Steve Bruce Prove Pointless?

A Villa supporter gives their opinion on the road ahead for Villa

By Robert Smith

Falling Short

So Villa failed to go up…

It was always a possibility, evident from the early part of the season, when we only won one of our first seven games. Ultimately another nine points would have seen us pip Cardiff for second place. We all know there were many games where we could have gained those elusive points.

Hull on the opening day, Brentford and Middlesbrough (down to 10-men after less than five minutes) at home, blowing a two-goal lead against Sheffield United, then QPR, Bolton, Norwich, and Hull again at the KFC stadium or whatever its called. There’s just so many, it’s a bit painful to recall. So why didn’t we get them?

Hanging Tough

There’s been lots of  talk about the inconsistent performance level, negative tactics, poor substitutions, but ultimately for me all we have lacked is toughness.

Its 11 v 11 at the end of the day and when we have matched our opponent’s commitment to the cause, we have almost always come out on top.

Embed from Getty Images

Perhaps inevitably, the Wembley game was like the season all rolled into one, with Villa starting badly, standing off the opposition and allowing them to dominate play, then realising too late what was required to succeed, leaving us huffing and puffing, and falling short, again.

The Manager Question.

It’s hard to criticize Steve Bruce given the personal challenges he’s faced this season, while in football terms he’s fought back from what looked like an inevitable dismissal around Christmas and taken us to the brink of promotion, all while handling himself with dignity throughout. For this, he has earned my respect and that of most Villa fans. But is he the man to lead us forward?


This starts with his failure to inject steel to a midfield that’s been a weak point since he took over in autumn 2016. Glenn Whelan and Mile Jedinak have acquitted themselves well but were always a little long in the tooth for such a physical role over an immensely tough 46 game season.

This leaves Grealish having to drop deeper to help out and thus not hurting the opposition where it matters most. Up front, we have needed a big, burly striker who would get on the end of crosses from Adomah and Elmohamady. Grabban has proved a decent loan signing overall (eight goals), but he was poor at Wembley and in the few weeks before, suggesting his commitment to our cause may not have been absolute or that Villa needed more of a target man.

Fulham signed Aleksandar Mitrović in January, and his physical presence has got them out of jail on several occasions. If Brucie had managed a similar loan/signing, we might be where they are now.

Tactically, our manager struggles when we go a goal down. Throwing on attacking players at random when no midfield is left to supply them is just nonsense and is a lesson he should have learned a long time ago. Hopefully he has now.


Despite the above, we came bloody close. Ultimately one bad 45 minutes from promotion. Steve Bruce is exactly the sort of manager we need to get us out of this league. When he took over, we were looking over our shoulders towards League One, and he has fairly quickly transformed us into a unit that was almost good enough to go up.

We will inevitably lose several key players this summer, but if the club’s management team remains there’s a good chance we can replace players quickly and go again next season, which after all is only a couple of months away.

We will also be operating with less money, and Steve’s experience in taking Blues and Hull to the Premier League will prove invaluable here (I think he spent a bit to achieve this – Ed).

I’ve often wondered if, as a down to earth guy from the north-east, he’s more comfortable hustling on a smaller budget. After all, his loan players (Snodgrass, Johnstone, Grabban) have so far proved better value than his larger permanent signings (Hogan/Lansbury).

The Players

Some key men will leave this summer. Snodgrass, Terry and Grabban for certain, Samba and Johnstone too. James Chester will inevitably be of interest to several Premier League clubs, and we might struggle to hang on to him. After all, he is following playing in a European Championship semi-final with the prospect of a third season in the Championship.

Grealish will get offers too, but unless they come from the very, very top, I expect him to stay for next season at least. Our full backs have looked vulnerable and might need looking at, and reinforcing the middle is a must. That said, I won’t bang on about who we might buy or promote from the U23s because everything, everything depends on the financial fair play (FFP) situation. Strange to think the biggest influence on next season might not come from any of our playing squad or management team, but there it is.

Embed from Getty Images


We could be in a right mess here, it seems we might have to take action now to avoid a points deduction in the future, and this does not bode well for this summer’s transfer dealings.

It could have the double-whammy of making it tougher to recruit good players, while making it harder to convince those already here that its worth sticking with us. But fear not, the manager has made excellent use of loan deals this season and if he stays, I expect him to do the same next time around.

Cardiff are just the most recent example of a club with limited resources making it to the top league. Huddersfield, Bournemouth, Swansea, Barnsley, Bolton, Derby and West Brom  have also done it, to name a few. Burnley managed it a few years ago and they’re now in Europe. Our present manager has done it too and anyone calling for his dismissal needs to remember that a guy who achieved promotion with scant resources at Hull and our dearest neighbours has a good chance of doing the same at Villa Park.

Our Owners

Its hard not to feel some sympathy for Tony Xia, he and the Recon Group potentially rescued us from our situation getting any worse ala Sunderland and have spent a sizeable chunk of cash.

Tony’s very communicative with us fans, and insists the club is too. Ticket prices are reasonable and there’s a sense that he really enjoys owning the Villa. That said, Recon have gambled with our clubs finances and how they handle the whole financial fair play situation will really show us what they’re made of. This may well be the first time I’ve ever hoped a wealthy corporation manages to avoid playing fair on the financial front, and it’s probably the last too.

The Future

What we don’t need right now is any unnecessary upheaval. If Steve Bruce carries on at Villa Park, we should support him while he guides the club through what could be a difficult summer.

Dean Smith may well end up being our manager at some point, but unless Bruce decides to walk away now is not the right time for him at the Villa.

Despite our current position, there is a good feeling around Villa Park, with the ownership and management team both sensible and experienced. Contrast this with Leeds, about to embark on a morally horrendous tour of Myanmar at the insistence of their new owners,  and we can see how much worse things could have been.

Our club has not had any stability since O’Neill walked out almost a decade ago. We need it now more than ever. Get this right, and we could be celebrating next May. Panic, and we might find ourselves marooned down here for a while yet.


Follow Robert on Twitter here: @pkingsspotkick

These supporter opinion pieces are not necessarily the views of My Old Man Said


  1. we got so close being at times awful,,, the injuries are what cost us but that said there are big failings with this team,,,,, and that is why we are so negative at times,, and lets not forget how many games johnstone kept us in it,,,
    and thats why we need to consider keeping bruce,,,, for one more season,,,
    the failings are obvious,,, too slow at the back,,, elmo needed to push on more,,, hutton at left back,,,
    im not slagging him off he has been immense but we need a decent lb,,,
    hourihane defensively weak, goes missing,,, no one capable of picking out hogan,, hoofed balls to no one hoofed balls to midgets,, endless crosses and corners with no threat,, no free kicks scored direct , grealish running too much and failing to play in players making runs in the center of the pitch, johnstone distribution,,
    bad at defending corners and crosses especially diagonal,,,
    there are more but that will do for now,,,
    if,,,,,,,, and its a big if,, if bruce can address these problems we will be much better and therefore
    maby get automatic promotion,,, and i think there is every chance of us being better next season
    green rhm davis lyden o hare ready to step up,,,, and steer too ,,, jedi whelan and benny b rotating,,
    maby kodja back to his best,, green and adoma chopping and changing
    hogan lansbury mccormack delaet gardner tishibola gil gollini elphick maby taylor and richards
    sold or moved on,,,
    the depth will have to be the kids,,, but it could happen,,,,
    but i still think smith could be the answer,,, or chris wilder
    smith i think would like to be our manager and would get more from our starved forwards

  2. Does anyone think we would be having this conversation if Bruce had no history of getting promotion; answer is no he would already have packed his bags. Whilst taking on board his personal problems and the fact he appears to be a nice man, this is Aston Villa the business and if you don’t get results you face the sack, and let’s be honest aside from the games mentioned that we should have won, some of the performances when we did win were bloody awful. I struggle to say who is the best person to manage villa, but it isn’t Bruce, so let’s hope that somebody who knows how to nurture the kids and give players a chance and not just a couple of games here and there, takes this club that I love with a passion, forward.

  3. Bruce himself admitted the poor start was due to missing Jack Grealish at the start of the season..even when we got him back the teams he played around him did not get the best from him imo. Too many times Jack was left to work his magic in isolation as Adomah or Snodgrass were told to hug wings and get crosses in.
    In the best game jack had at Wembley vs Liverpool he had dynamic trio of players on his wavelength able to take a pass and move off him. This season villa looked best when players were in and around him as he had options and the vision to pick a pass.
    Steve Bruce all too often this year put Defensive stability above dare and held his beloved 3 centre back shape back no matter what happened.
    More telling as has been said was his tactical naivety when were were chasing a game of loading the field with forwards…but with no one to offer a supply line.
    Villa never threatens pace as Cardiff did and never controlled the ball in a manner of wolves or Fulham….
    If we scored first then more often than not that was enough as we played the percentage and fair enough, but if we went behind or couldn’t breaks team then the game plans always seemed disjointed.
    Ether way whatever choice is made on the manager (and I’m Bruce Out) we need to make this decision very early and in the next 2 weeks at most to allow everyone at the club..coach, players, fans, owners to get behind whatever decision is made.

  4. Glossing over Bruce’s manifest failings on the basis that ‘he must’ve learned by now’ simply doesn’t wash.
    ‘He made it before with smaller clubs therefore can do it with us’ no, it does not follow. Transfer and loan dealings – to what purpose or was it just lets buy the best players at their clubs and everything will work out – just like Torres at Chelsea eh? Buy immobile dinosaurs and ALWAYS play them ahead of the kids. Tactics? set up to defend a 0-0 lead and hope for the best. I could go on. Bruce MUST go and go now, he has never been up to the job. Dean Smith or someone else with brains, a system, an ability to bring on the kids, an ability to get the best out of a tight budget and for Chrissakes positive, exciting, take a few risks, fast, intelligent attacking football and no more of the sideways, sideways, back, sideways, sideways, back, hoof crap we’ve been served up for so long now..

  5. Colin,I’m with you, utter tripe , absolutely “dinasour tactically .” Talks the talk, then
    Stares bewildered when the mercenaries don’t show up. The midfield of one player
    Grealish,beggars belief. Boycott the academy all season. Stumbles upon Davis, never
    plays Hogan as he should be played. Landsbury was another,who ground to a halt via
    Bruce. If Xia continues with Bruce, it will be another wasted season of hoof by pass
    No midfield. One Dimensional football. Sorry Stevep45, you’ve been left wanting Nuno, Joka,
    have revealed all. So did QPR, Norwich. Bolton.

  6. Hull City supporter here, re Bruce, he spent shed loads of money to get us in the Premier League, we are just startIng to recover.

  7. Has anyone even considered the cost of replacing Bruce and his staff? More financial despair… I actually agree with this article and think ATM Steve Bruce is the right man for us.. he has a great rapport and respect from the top managers in the Premier… this will be vital in bringing in the right loan players

  8. A one sided article by an obvious Bruce fan I for one don’t agree and think Bruce should go ASAP, I have nothing against him personally but for me he’s tactically inept and too defensive and we need a younger attack minded manager to take us forward, if Bruce stays it will just be more of the same and unlikely that we will even make the play offs next time around.

Comments are closed.