View on Dean Smith From Villa Park is Currently Different Than Twitter

Embed from Getty Images

Villa Park Twelve Man

Up until 10 minutes to go against Wolves at Villa Park, match-going fans at Villa Park this season had been blessed with an unbeaten start to the season. Last season, across the Premier League, the lack of home crowd advantage was clear to be seen, as most club’s away form greatly improved with the playing field more even.

With fans returning this season, it was hoped that Fortress Villa Park would provide the backbone to Villa’s campaign…hopefully, despite recent setbacks, it still might.

After increasing complacency to the importance of match-going fans due to club’s ever increasing TV rights revenues, the recent experience of what football is like without fans, highlighted how empty stands can make a difference for both TV viewers and a players alike.

While obviously supporters create a match’s atmosphere, what has been forgotten is how a stadium’s crowd provide a better indication of a fanbase’s current mood than Twitter’s often nameless and unquantifiable pool of opinion.

The local press, clickbait football media and even outlets like the BBC, increasingly are content to look to Twitter for a litmus test of opinion, as it enables them to cobble together a few Tweets to create any desired narrative that will get clicks and engagement.

You just need four or five random Twitter accounts with tweets attacking a manager for their latest loss, to spew a bunch of articles that will get ‘hashtag [insert name] out’ trending. We’ve already seen it this season for Nuno, Munoz, Ole, Raffa and Smith.

Thank god supporters have returned to grounds though.

Embed from Getty Images

Pollice Verso

When the road is rocky, the Holte End at Villa Park reminds me in many ways of a Roman Coliseum crowd at times. It ultimately provides the pollice verso on the fate of a struggling manager.

Its judgment has proven over time to be measured, and neither rash or unreasonable.

Even in a pretty woeful last decade or so, where the likes of Gérard Houllier, Alex McLeish, Paul Lambert, Remi Garde Tim Sherwood, Roberto Di Matteo and Steve Bruce have had poor periods, Villa Park is largely tolerant and supportive up until the point the manager really needs to be given the thumbs down.

McLeish is perhaps the best example. While a misjudged managerial appointment that was unsurprisingly afforded no honeymoon period (especially on social media), the Villa Park faithful at least gave him a chance and had a certain amount of empathy to his situation.

The club was a shambles on and off the pitch, so when supporter’s patience was taken too far, namely Villa throwing away a lead in a vital home clash against Bolton, it was ultimately the fierce response of the crowd that night that effectively rubber-stamped the sacking of McLeish for the end of the season.

While #SmithOut may trend on Twitter, at Villa Park you’d struggle to hear Smith’s position currently up for discussion. When Villa went down to 10-men, 2-1 down against West Ham, the Upper Holte at least, let out a defiant extended chant of ‘Dean Smith’s Claret and Blue Army.”

It was the kind of rally call in adversity you’d expect from supporters. After all, if one of your own is not having a good time, support is often the most helpful way of remedying the situation and getting improvement.

What does entitled vitriol and unconstructive negativity achieve? Especially when it provides no alternative solutions to the situation.

So far the only solutions to Villa’s recent poor performances that Twitter have thrown up are to play a young midfielder who has less than 90 minutes combined to his name in a Villa first team shirt, and to get a Portuguese manager in, who’s literally got ‘Managerial Mercenary’ stamped on his forehead.

30% off Selected Villa Shirts Below – Code AFFKB30

Road to Improvement

Considering the upheaval in preseason and the frustrating injuries, Villa’s start to the season was always going to be compromised.

Yes, they should have done better, but while supporters understandably decry what they’re watching from the stands at Villa Park during games, they do so with context and the hope that Smith can turn things around.

 The ‘this is a must-win game or it’s Smith Out’ Twitter ultimatum approach to each game is nonsense. Look at Newcastle United, unlimited wealth, yet they’re struggling to get a ‘wow factor’ manager in.

The expectation of Villa needing to be better goes without saying (and MOMS will discuss it in detail elsewhere), but it’s just a shame that for the moment at least, the online version of Villa fans can’t be more like the proverbial twelfth man in times of trouble.


Follow and listen to the Podcast on Spotify


  1. A national newspaper recently ran a piece on a famous Hungarian coach, Bela Guttmann, who won titles in Europe and South America. One of his philosophies was that a coach should stay no longer than three years at a club. After that, he said, players became jaded, lost belief in the coach’s system, or it was simply that opposition coaches worked out how to beat you. There are exceptions to this. Ferguson at Manchester Utd. Or Wenger at Arsenal (although there’s an argument Wenger wasn’t successful at the end of his time and over stayed his welcome). And examples of Guttmann’s philosophies working. Chelsea. Or more extremely, Watford . So maybe, on the third anniversary of Dean Smith’s appointment, it is time for reflection. The fanbase is split. More time, or time up?

    • I think Villa are beating themselves at the moment. There is also the hope you’d see a better Smith with better players, as his approach perhaps suits more talented players. My concern was the defensive side of his thinking, but that seemed to have been sorted out post-Project Restart…until this season.

  2. I think smith is just a younger Bruce.

    He struggles to make the changes needed.

    I think a top 10 finish if we are lucky is his best.

  3. I understand Andy’s point. I agree with some of his concerns. But losing one of the most creative players in the league, and a defensive coach, and your long time assistant has clearly caused issues. Smith never managed to work out how to play without our previous number ten when he was injured. And a set piece coach who seems obsessed with long throws is not promising. I still believe Smith should be given the chance to turn things around. But I reserve the right to get an itchy trigger finger if the Southampton and Brighton games don’t go our way.

  4. Not sure I can agree. We sit in the holte upper and 95% of fans there have seen enough of Dean Smith’s football which appears to be give it to the left centre back to hoof up the pitch and play for 2nd balls.

    Love to be proven wrong tomorrow night but it feels like he has lost the dressing room with Buendia/Sanson strops and arguing on the pitch. I counted far too many excuses from him as to why we lost the West Ham game and even today his presser says we are playing well and all is well I’m behind the scenes?!? Performances have been poor; This is turning a little bit Bruce esq for me.

    Like the man but think the time has come for a change and there is no disgrace in him being honest with himself in saying he’s done his best and taken us as far as he can and walking away before it turns sour and as you say the thumbs all point down!

    • 95%? Did you do a survey?! Seriously speaking though, this is not the reality I’ve heard from the Upper Holte. You have to remember, at Villa Park, it’s only been 10 mins against Wolves and the Hammers game, that you could consider adverse experiences so far. If they held onto win that Wolves game, they would have had the 3rd best home form of the PL.

      This is not a case of constant poor results at Villa Park.

      Speaking of results, four out of the five away games have been against the Super League Six.

      There’s a lot of other context to make calling for Smith’s head a tad premature at this point.

  5. The tone I’ve come to expect in MOM’s blogs. Sane, intelligent, analysis. We’ve made progress at every point of Smith’s tenure. And who would have contested progress still wasn’t being made after defeating a previously unbeaten Everton 3-0, drawing at Chelsea in the League Cup and only going out on penalties, then winning at Old Trafford for the first time in years? And at 2-0 against Wolves with fifteen minutes to go? So we’ve lost three on the trot plus fifteen minutes. He has to be given time to prove he can turn this mini run of poor results around.

Comments are closed.